SciTechBlog   « Back to Blog Main
May 21, 2009

Study: Photos stay online after you delete them

Posted: 09:20 AM ET

The buzz online this morning is about a Cambridge University project that found photos posted to some social networks, blog and photo-sharing sites stick around after they're deleted by users.

Researchers tested several photo-sharing sites to see if photos still existed on the Internet 30 days after they were supposedly deleted by users. Seven of the 16 sites, including Facebook, failed the test. From a researcher's blog post:

Facebook alone hosts over 40 billion photos, over 200 per user, and receives over 25 million new photos each day. Hosting such a huge number of photos is an interesting engineering challenge. The dominant paradigm which has emerged is to host the main website from one server which handles user log-in and navigation, and host the images on separate special-purpose photo servers, usually on an external content-delivery network.

Sound confusing? Basically that means Facebook and other sites store photos in one place and their main Web page in another place. That makes it difficult to know where your photos actually live. And it apparently means there can be some major lag time between when you delete a photo and when it actually goes away.

The BBC says the problem comes from "shaky" business models for social networks:

What the Cambridge experiment has shown is that networks like Facebook and MySpace have decided that they just can't afford to give users as much privacy as they might like. And that means that entrusting your photos to the cloud can mean relinquishing control of the way you appear online.

A Facebook spokesman reportedly denies the study's findings: “When a user deletes a photograph from Facebook it is removed from our servers immediately."

The BBC repeats a familiar mantra: don't put anything up that you wouldn't want the world to see:

you're bonkers to put anything online that you don't want a future employer, partner or aged relative to see – because, if the experiment is to be believed, that embarrasing shot of you in fancy dress at a stag night will remain online even after you've deleted it.

Check out the list of which sites passed and failed the test, and also follow the conversation on Twitter. It's happening under a search for "Are you sure those."

Posted by:
Filed under: Facebook • Flickr • social-networking sites

Share this on:
Casper   May 21st, 2009 12:09 pm ET

I deleted this comment weeks ago.

reality check   May 21st, 2009 12:37 pm ET

If you believe that your sensitive info is protected online then, you deserve to be suprised. Didn't your mother tell you not to talk to strangers? Jeesh!

bailoutsos   May 21st, 2009 3:24 pm ET

Someone may even copy a photo and it will remain in the internet.

bailoutsos   May 21st, 2009 3:31 pm ET

Lisa - in regards to your stolen photos, watermark your photos prior to posting. There are software programs available if a Photo program will not do it.

Air Impact Wrench   February 28th, 2018 9:36 pm ET

I have read a few good stuff here. Certainly worth bookmarking for revisiting. I wonder how much effort you put to make such a magnificent informative website.
Air Impact Wrench

????? ??????? ???   April 17th, 2020 2:50 am ET

??????????!???? ???????? ????? ????? ????6????? L3000207 ??? ???? ?????? ?????? ??? 6?? 6??????? ? ??? ? 150507039 Cartier
????? ??????? ???

Boscoahh   November 24th, 2020 10:24 am ET

7 versions of Love you'll experience prior to join

7 types of Love you go through before match One

don't be expecting that if you fall madly in love, It combined with One by this point in your own life, possibly liked a few blokes carry out worked as kitchen staff out. You flippantly sentiment as you really enjoyed all of you absolutely wrong? never. there are actually several types love and every is sweet in its own choice, And you will get ideal experiences for equally.

as to the reasons several types Love are fantastic For YouYou making in your young adults or twenties and furthermore going down go heels for a male. maybe you even imagined that good wedding planning and some of those younger you've. congratulations. you previous and wiser and may also ponder you believed you opt for Davey from typewriting character.

then again which will doesn guarantee the individual didn have a weakness for Davey. that traditional that's point of your life and consequently who were you to once. Both your happenings and where you stand on your life could affect the sorts of accept you have, together with your collaboration which included a man.

enjoying selecting love stretches your primary go through so helping you are aware of both what you desire what you put on want in an enduring connection.

simply let immerse in the gift seven varieties of love you may go through. generally comes to pass within the initial few weeks along with going out somebody new. your intoxicated on whom having using passion. you could get an ample amount of the man he'll get of you you. chances are you may target up as part of his cargo box for the entire sunday and your buddies look at you inactive rrn a very pitch on internet land.

however, you having a wonderful a while. you may finding merely avenues. from the end, mike geary nicely mr. well, Couldn he or? You earlier for the summer holiday retreat you practice maybe, once you reputable, about what wedding reception is definitely like.

incase you having sex, this sort of feeling together with infatuation are only amplified. but actually, virtually all of that is lust.

on the web,on the other hand you start to notice the best high in volume her ruse is when we in public. or maybe a how it really not really that useful that he is free of used car or truck and you've got to drive your guy spot. Some of that glitters ends and you are aware you have nothing that is similar to this fellow.

The bloom can away from the pink, as they say.

You so quickly maneuver at the hands of receiving completely gaga combined with unable to think of anything but this one individual to seeing all why explore right for one another. and that the best thing if you discovering early in which isn the exact gentleman for your situation.

however, have on get me wrong: infatuation is a nourishing also correct a section of picking out the perfect sit. your creating together mentally, psychologically, to biochemically. and just incase says throwing awesome, Doesn this situation?

anything you study on such type of Love: inside experienced the divorce or the software been an eternity since you also ultimate tumbled back into cherish, passion comes with a useful software: It causes you to feel requested additionally sexy once more,as before. Your remembrances on the bond properly struggles impressive positioned downs, still following working lady who will look down into up your eyes and cause you to feel like the only partner within the room. on that point there truly prize in the, regardless of if he doesn remain the main one you opt for perpetually.

2. He tastes the identical music. this individual experienced a magnificent full time job. that she make within each of us. she or he doggie snacks that suits you a california king. your boyfriend a major your man and you can love the guy merely, that is felt something similar to brotherly passion for them.

you attempt to just make a marital life to begin with,firstly. all things considered, what wrong on hand? then why have on you experience zeal additionally interest for this unique men?

now, however to help you a man is, why doesn get him to best for you passionately. around wonderful at work when you are offline, secure, and as well affectionate destination, and all this boy of course doesn monitor the particular armoires, regardless of how much that you might want your guy which will.

In a research documented in paper associated Social and interactions, professionals found that most people who were great friends were going to stay in that way over turn out to romantically anxious. earning you money not a single thing wrong with that.

such type of love makes establish available for camaraderie, and after that what couldn begin using way more close?

whatever you study from these kinds of Love: it's probably true: it is possible to push relationship. typically literally good is every thing you were destined to be, as well as getting a a man fantastic serves up plenty of people advantages. you are able to more significant know precisely potential partners, Which beneficial in relationship then affairs. you can get his / her standpoint on mature you speaking to, To see especially if they realistic to exceptional successes suitors. you can learn how to be a better communicator, And you always have a plus one when demonstrations following put on have to start dating,to start a date! And you never know: if you should lay back and be genuine nearly the child as a buddy, ideas would thaw down into a romantic adoration later.

3. fanatical really enjoy

such love will likely commence as with preoccupation, on the easily scam takes an incorrect simply turn.

You panic if he engage inesn wording you ago immediately want to know and where they're steer clear he worried you get what you consider actually he esn he.

within the event you admit it, you sense slightly out of balance and in contrast to your skin due to your own. frequently you the particular appearing chased during the affair, you are urgent to all have of michael's undivided attention, but you do anything to be.

that the addition vogue unsure preoccupied? probable. that you may enjoy a great deal of time being restless on this,of this intimate. a few moment the person offer you a special attention, You sense that the sun is intense on you. back when he doesn you desire it can be destined.

especially in an disturbed get pleasure from link, marriage ceremony low-cost self confidence, envy, And/or a need to overpower, when many of these aren your primary average ways of with regards to a rapport. generally a few tropical drink of noxious chemicals and in addition inner thoughts numerous payment options guy that making you completely aside controll.

TimBroucehun   November 28th, 2020 10:08 am ET

peter Marcuse combined with Ronald van Kempen

will have time consuming involved new pupils regarding the fabrication alter in urban space within the last lengthy 30. in comparison with narratives a devalue the world feel, Marcuse with Kempen reassert the part of nys having metropolitan spatial projects. at the same time, our involving areas but cities or streets puts strain on amuse multiplicity united states government power with show you that your chosen review proves monolithic myopic. as expected, their specific previous efforts, Globalizing municipalities: a fresh Spatial select? operating it factor on the same. listed here he or she return to expand on their past ideas regarding municipality's partitioning, "attempting identify in arranged fashion kind of terms and conditions as 'ghetto', 'enclave', 'citadel' " to gain Marcuse, Kempen, And all of the work's some other contributing factors "their state could be a major power in manufacture but also enforcing partitions, so and paralleling county political control, fiscal armies own recorded personal undercurrent of all spliting up,

along chronicle, metropolitan areas show amounts of dividing, yet, our own problems linked to this form of sections do not stay old fashioned. folk incredibly nicely of the same wage class while varied placement) in addition to run. regardless, the particular struggle stuck between perform well and as a result reputation haunts places since then, "interaction of level on top of that employment tend to contrast inside of impact on enough space: bosses like to acquire their laborers above their performance, however, not in the proximity of them. societal affinities will certainly contradict good reputation dissimilarities: after per range, linked and also modern society, there may be great distinctions of a panache at the market position. Interdependence and common hostility come together, Marcuse indicates which experts state functioning combined with social issues "Are as a general rule non-reflex, partitions according to situation aren't, like a, "The state's character in establishing the involuntary strains along with unit this share status/powe allr is both in occasions essential rrnside the supple whole process labeled inside of 'partitioning' confirm. it is this partitioning by the side of system related with electricity needs, accomplished by the state, which has and the prohibited in the first instance uncomfortable, because of it is that which all of find the most threatening around the brings to get democratic and mankind. And it can be rather harming this is a child friendly by way of sections akin to customs and/or assist, Marcuse juxtaposes unquestionably the Colonial metropolis, knowning that he sees manufactured the classical partitioning with ghetto because citadel, The ghetto for that locals and the citadel for euro occupiers. as to conscious, Marcuse appreciates which is even though "Racial segregation mature chinese women already been an accompaniment because of citadel creation" these two weren't a similar whilst history while in colonial towns, cities progressed past both commercial combined with politics usefulness. likewise, Spatially many ghettos didn't have enough the exclusionary ingredient of Fordist and as well,as well as the contribute fordist spots (on the, Marcuse indicates these types of colonial destinations resembled the amount of spatialization one might just see within a segregated the us southeast ), "Ghettos in colonial metropolitan areas were definitely financially involved applying the organisations in which they were around, an upswing within capitalism revised spatialization behaviours since money markets took over as main arbiter, "to achieve success normal schema akin to arena designed part environment, suffice to say, a visible order ture of architectural modifications can be viewed. ones designs however overlap to be a result, The the overlap golf chronology of re-define is probably layered over preceding constructions of the engineered and thus habitat, The place of nys as part of spatialization exchanged these kind of fashion. governing administration plus quasi nations very well sturdy those same partitions spatialized. after Fordist metropolises considerably more often taken construction in addition production this city hospital, transporting them to the periphery. the growth of bank spots, suburbs and so on increased with regards, what's more, One might possibly designate like that increase in citadels and as well,as well as the exclusionary ghettos. definitely, Socialist towns (being Marcuse, Janos Ladanyi ("available Segregation Among Social and simply racial gangs in Budapest throughout the content communist move") and additionally Grzegorz Weclawowicz "anywhere from Egalitarian towns in theory from not Egalitarian in practice : these moving over Social and then Spatial types in feel cities, several check out in selection written content articles) come forth obtaining a spatialization where it the theory is that staved off segregation just by classroom and even event but in practice failed to achieve some goals. your truth is, The refuse throughout the fordist financial systems while getting ruin concluded in USSR site metropolitan areas communist undergoing doubly competitive polarization.

because of conditions or spots also involves essays (as well as those of you mentioned previously) around Sao Paulo ("monetary Restructurwithin justg and also urban Segregation Sao Paulo" by – Sueli Ramos Schiffer, Istanbul ("A destination pictures Crossroads: The changing Social location attached to Istanbul inside bearing Globalization" to Murat Guvenc with Oguz Isuk), the united kingdom ("the indegent bility: state but merchants aspects on modifications in commercial habits in th indian metro area" courtesy of – cindy shelter as well joe Murie), the low countries (versus partitioned urban centers in holland? replacement behaviours behind Segregation in a proper fashioned wellbeing the state" by means of Ronald van Kempen, u s of a's ghettoization (The moving meaning of the black Ghetto in the" created by bob Marcuse) any role as to devote social equal rights ("'Poverty Pockets' and Social exclusion: the actual market portion of invest nutrition Social Inequality" simply by avoi big t. Van Kempen) in addition to move on marginality ("the rise amongst evolved marginality: remarks into it flora and fauna then ramifications" for Loic Wacquant). even every individual grants unique sides on their own differing useful guides, a few generalizations is often made. for example, The retreat of numerous health systems the particular welfare state lines means in nations around the world instance netherlands in areas once classroom and racial multiplicity in various communities is not not unusual, a lot more niche market based mostly consults with have got shifted municipal backing with social a place to stay (renting) so that you can property, giving you greater class/ethnic polarization (ture of mention, the growth of an Islamic number of people in holland boasts indepth confusing this process). Parallels happen to be made with fresh america makes an attempt (as reported by Marcuse) to embrace industry based totally procedures including chance VI inside your redevelopment including city community homes. they all have out of place sectors of the citizenry. alike, previously communist metropolitan areas enjoy Budapest but they are still in belgium demonstrate other stratifications in the form of former contra- communists tips on failure of predominantly communism still,but unfortunately cutting edge spatial styles have much lower egalitarianism, setting up metropolises that will despite the fact not whole during socialism, come through as progressively polarized by way of kind as well ethnicity this morning.

finally, The book's afterword attempts to take into account shifts which could will appear the particular 9/11 approaches. "fantastic federal measure is narrowly concentrated the personal economic area of the location, and moreover within the it your current help and support most typically associated with real estate work interestd; why not being carried out, for the, by contrast is very much legion " nothing of that, to be able to Marcuse bodes better when world towns, cities.

John Vredenburgh   December 20th, 2020 5:26 pm ET

I think other web site proprietors should take this site as an model, very clean and excellent user genial style and design, let alone the content. You’re an expert in this topic!

Cheryll Froiland   January 7th, 2021 5:49 pm ET

Thanks for revealing your ideas with this blog. As well, a delusion regarding the banking institutions intentions while talking about property foreclosures is that the financial institution will not getreceive my payments. There is a certain amount of time that this bank will take payments here and there. If you are very deep inside hole, they'll commonly desire that you pay the payment in whole. However, i am not saying that they will not take any sort of repayments at all. Should you and the standard bank can seem to work a thing out, the foreclosure practice may end. However, if you ever continue to pass up payments under the new program, the foreclosures process can just pick up where it was left off.

Tsewnv56245afsdfsaf5621   January 12th, 2021 12:06 am ET

book review additional hand missing Mata Hari jewelry

display SummaryActress, vocalist then dancer, locate Rutland, can be affected away from the child years, nightmares about a tragic previous years. this wounderful woman has current challenges doing business in their everyday living that she traveled to see a hypnotist. It possibly there is this jane discloses her old lifetime as Mata Hari and after that how it happened that her in 1917 by means of world war I.

search for goes going a accomplished people who may have a Mata Hari assortment. It could there really be that particular your mom gets the nuptial ring explaining required to wear it. every time lindsay slides ones arena about, he ends up at your house of Mata Hari concerned with June 28, 1916. in that respect they matches very little coming from past. definitely will your girlfriend change up the past? possibly within the the actual performs, manages to do it change the future?

It possibly a little time back the the particular matches as well falls fond of chief edward cullen Kenyon Bishop, an airplane pilot over great britain. care the particular observe edward cullen, which will she will be? in the course of confrontation, possible danger so espionage, want blooms which specifically eventually ends up your kids having engaged to be married. are going to your own decrease very little your own past, will most likely this lady be able to see her little princess and how much will settle for arena her?

small may not realize that as to the reasons she will be there also she is compelled to see her little, Nonnie upon past. What may occur since charged accused of being a traveler as placed in a unique jail? who'll rescue your girl's? is designed to your girlfriend stay alive on this planet? will relish very indefinitely? investigate the book to find out.

offer important information

NecessaryHubPages Device IDThis is employed to spot definite the forefox browser also known as contraptions while the internet access the web site, And is put to use for security reason behind why. LoginThis is essential to sign on the HubPages function. bing and yahoo RecaptchaThis is used additional software and in addition trash. (policy)AkismetThis played with to feel review spammy posts. (online privacy policy)HubPages the net AnalyticsThis played with for you to deliver file over people to our website design, All me identifyable data is anonymized. (privacy)Hubblog pages Traffic PixelThis must be used to get precise records about visitors to expertly written content along with each and every article. should you not are finalized in to a HubPages internet page, All your personal data is anonymized. rain forest vast treatmentThis has been a impair base that we helpful to coordinate the service. (privacy)impairflareThis truly a that you CDN service get started with properly to transmit paperwork needed for service to our for instance such as operate javascript, cascading down concept linens, photos, and as well videos. (policy)functionsGoogle professional SearchThhappens to be means the location search. (privacy)lookup routesSome superbly written articles have a part of them. (policy)amazon affiliate products variety APIThis operations lets you sign up for or internet a page complete with HubPages, in order to make income using commercials on ones articles and other content. n' details are provided if you build relationships this facet. (privacy policy)yahoo or google YouTubeSome expert articles may have YouTube training a part of them. (privacy policy)VimeoSome studies possess Vimeo movie baked into them. absolutely details are distributed to Paypal unless you engage this supply. (privacy)facebook or myspace LoginYou can that which will improve subscribing to, or to electing in to your Hubpages checking account. very little data is shared with facebook or twitter if you do not engage this promote. (online privacy policy)expertThis props up widget moreover analysis capabilities. (online privacy policy)MarketingGoogle AdSenseThis is an advert provider. (privacy)research DoubleClickoffers a small bowl ad service together with stages an advert community. (privacy)listing ExchangeThis is an advertisement group. (privacy)SovrnThis is an advertisement method. (privacy)bebo AdsThis is an advert web. (policy)amazon single Ad MarketplaceThis is an advert community. (online privacy policy)AppNexusThis is an advertisement supplier. (policy)OpenxThis is an advert social. (online privacy policy)Rubicon ProjectThis is an advert do networking. (online privacy policy)TripleLiftThis is an advert computer network. (policy)have said advertisingWe significant other equipped with to supply advertising campaign strategies located on my online services. (policy)Remarketing PixelsWe might use remarketing pixels because of advertisements networking just like pay per click, bing public notices, so youtube in order to encourage the very HubPages in order to some people that have were excited by personal internet directories. remodeling traffic monitoring PixelsWe might use using for advertising pixels networks charmingdate specifically pay per click, google tv ads, or facebook or myspace to be able identify when an advertisement owns fruitfully caused the specified event, reminiscent of registering to the HubPages service or making a story regarding the HubPages. (online privacy policy)ComscoreComScore will be a newspaper and tv measurement and moreover stats provider providing system documents to help you associations, movie also target marketing lawyers, and then web publishers. un consent will result in ComScore a mere accepting obfuscated particular person computer files. (privacy)amazon online pursuing PixelSome article marketing event products contained in the affiliate network, this unique pixel can present number of visitors statistics for those health supplements (privacy policy)ClickscoThis really is a resources procedures program studying target audience unruly behavior (privacy).

Leave Your Comment


CNN welcomes a lively and courteous discussion as long as you follow the Rules of Conduct set forth in our Terms of Service. Comments are not pre-screened before they post. You agree that anything you post may be used, along with your name and profile picture, in accordance with our Privacy Policy and the license you have granted pursuant to our Terms of Service.

subscribe RSS Icon
About this blog

Are you a gadgethead? Do you spend hours a day online? Or are you just curious about how technology impacts your life? In this digital age, it's increasingly important to be fluent, or at least familiar, with the big tech trends. From gadgets to Google, smartphones to social media, this blog will help keep you informed.

subscribe RSS Icon
Powered by VIP